Quick takeaways
- You can cancel anytime in writing. The insurer may keep up to 10% of the unearned premium.
- Florida DFS says the refund is due within 15 working days after the cancellation date.
- Switching after a hurricane claim can restart your hurricane deductible for the rest of the year.
- Bind the new policy before you cancel, and never during a storm watch.
Say your policy renews in October, and in March a neighbor mentions a quote that beat yours by a wide margin. You don't have to wait seven months. Florida lets you cancel a homeowners policy whenever you want, and you get back the part of the premium you haven't used yet.
The trick is doing it in the right order and at the right time of year.
How much of my premium comes back?
The part you get back is called unearned premium. It's the share of the year you paid for but won't use. The starting point is the pro rata amount, which means in proportion to the time left.
The Florida Department of Financial Services says you can cancel at any time with a written request, and that the insurer may keep 10% of the unearned premium. A state rule sets the same floor. A short-rate refund, the kind that holds back a penalty, can't return less than 90% of the pro rata amount unless the insurer justified it to regulators.
Example: you paid $3,600 for a 12-month policy and cancel after 4 months. That leaves 8 months unused.
- Pro rata unearned premium: $3,600 x 8 / 12 = $2,400
- If the insurer keeps the full 10%: $2,400 x 0.10 = $240
- Smallest likely refund: $2,400 minus $240 = $2,160
Check it a second way: $2,400 x 0.90 = $2,160. Insurers count days, not months, so the real figure will be a little different. Your policy's cancellation section says whether your insurer keeps anything.
DFS says the refund is due within 15 working days after the cancellation date. If a premium finance company paid your premium, which is a lender that fronts the premium and bills you monthly, the refund goes to that company.
In what order should I switch?
Getting the order wrong is how people end up with a gap, a day or more with no coverage.
- Get the new policy bound. Binding means the new insurer has accepted you and set a start date. Ask for the start date you want, such as the first of next month.
- Get the new declarations page. That's the summary page with your limits, deductibles and policy number. Don't cancel anything until you have it.
- Send a written cancellation to the old insurer. Make it effective on the same date the new policy starts. Ask your old agent or insurer what form they want.
- Tell your mortgage servicer. Send the new declarations page and make sure the new policy lists your lender as mortgagee, the party paid along with you on a claim.
- Watch for the refund. Mark 15 working days from the cancellation date on your calendar and follow up if nothing arrives.
The Department of Financial Services notes that some companies may charge a penalty when coverage hasn't been continuous, so a gap can cost you on the next quote too.
When is switching a bad idea?
Most of the year, switching mid-policy works fine, with a few exceptions.
| Situation | Switch now? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Better quote, same coverage, calm weather | Usually fine | You get unearned premium back |
| You already had a hurricane claim this calendar year | Run the numbers first | A new insurer outside your current group starts a fresh hurricane deductible |
| A tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is up for Florida | Wait | Insurers may refuse to bind new coverage |
| You have an open claim | Fine, but the claim stays put | The old policy still handles damage that happened while it was in force |
| You're on Citizens and want to rewrite for a lower Citizens rate | No | Citizens cancels rewrites made only to get a lower rate |
The hurricane deductible row needs math. The Florida hurricane deductible applies once per calendar year across policies from the same insurer or insurer group. Move to a different group, and a later hurricane that year starts from zero.
Example, using the Department of Financial Services numbers: your home has $200,000 of dwelling coverage and a 2% hurricane deductible, so $4,000. A first hurricane does $2,000 of damage. You pay it all, and $2,000 of the deductible remains for the year. A second hurricane does $5,000 of damage.
- Same insurer: $2,000 deductible left, insurer pays $5,000 minus $2,000 = $3,000
- Switched to a new insurer group: full $4,000 deductible, insurer pays $5,000 minus $4,000 = $1,000
That's $2,000 less from the second claim. The rest of the rules, including when the hurricane window opens and closes, are on the Florida hurricane deductible page.
On storm timing, Citizens stops binding new coverage once a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is issued for any part of Florida. Other insurers can have similar rules. Shop between storms, or wait until the season ends on November 30.
What happens with my mortgage escrow?
If you pay insurance through escrow, an account your servicer holds to pay taxes and insurance, the servicer paid the old premium. Two questions matter, and you should ask them before you bind.
- How will the servicer pay the new insurer, and how fast?
- Where should the old insurer send the refund?
Get those answers in writing. If the switch leaves a hole, your lender can buy force-placed insurance, which protects the lender's interest, and add the cost to your loan. How the account adjusts to a new premium is covered in escrow and homeowners insurance.
What paperwork goes with me?
Most of what earned you credits with the old insurer can go to the new one.
- Wind mitigation report. The state form is valid for up to five years if the home has had no material changes. Inspections starting April 1, 2026 use a revised form. Hand the new insurer the report you have, or book a fresh wind mitigation inspection if yours is near five years old.
- 4-point inspection. Older homes often need one. Insurers use it to judge the age and condition of the roof, wiring, pipes and air conditioning.
- Roof permit or invoice. Proof of the roof's install year.
- Claims history. The new insurer will ask, and answers need to be exact.
What to do next
- Get quotes built on the same coverage you have now, using the side-by-side table in how to compare a home insurance renewal.
- Check the calendar and the tropics. Skip binding during a storm watch, and run the deductible math if you've had a hurricane claim this year.
- Bind the new policy, get the declarations page, then cancel the old one in writing for the same date.
- Send the new declarations page to your mortgage servicer and ask where the refund should go.
- Follow up on the refund after 15 working days.
Common questions
Is there a penalty for cancelling home insurance early in Florida?
The insurer may keep up to 10% of the unearned premium, according to the Florida Department of Financial Services. A Florida rule bars short-rate refunds below 90% of the pro rata amount unless the insurer justified them to regulators.
How long does it take to get my refund?
The Department of Financial Services says unearned premium must be returned within 15 working days after the cancellation takes effect. If a premium finance company paid your premium, the refund goes to that company.
Can I switch home insurance during hurricane season?
Yes, but not while a storm is threatening. Citizens stops binding new coverage once a tropical storm or hurricane watch or warning is issued for any part of Florida, and other insurers can have similar rules.
Do I need a new wind mitigation inspection to switch?
Usually not. A wind mitigation report on the state form is valid for up to five years if the home hasn't had material changes, so give your current report to the new insurer.
Sources
- Homeowners' Insurance: A Toolkit for Consumers, Florida Department of Financial Services
- Homeowners Insurance FAQ, Florida Department of Financial Services
- Rule 69O-170.010, Short Rate Cancellations and Fully Earned Premiums Prohibited, Florida Administrative Code (via Cornell Legal Information Institute)
- Florida's Hurricane Deductible, Florida Department of Financial Services
- 2025 Hurricane Season Information, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- July 2026 Rate, Rule, and Wind-Loss Mitigation Updates, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation