Quick takeaways
- Doing nothing is a choice. Citizens moves you to the offer with the lowest estimated premium.
- An offer no more than 20% above your Citizens renewal premium ends your Citizens eligibility.
- Once your policy is taken over, there's no 30-day window to go back to Citizens.
- Compare deductibles, roof terms and who backs the insurer, along with the price.
A common mistake with a takeout letter is setting it aside because it looks like junk mail. Citizens itself warns that failing to respond will get your policy transferred to a private insurer. Silence decides for you.
A takeout, which Citizens calls depopulation, is how private insurers pick up Citizens policies. Since 2023, Citizens says the program has moved more than 900,000 policyholders to private insurers approved by the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation.
What did I get in the mail?
The letter is titled either a Policyholder Choice Offer or a Policyholder Depopulation Offer. Inside is a packet that lists:
- Each private insurer that selected your policy
- Each insurer's estimated renewal premium
- Your estimated Citizens renewal premium
- Coverage worksheets comparing each offer with your Citizens policy
- An Offer Form with a registration code and a response deadline
Keep the Offer Form. You need the code on it to respond online.
Can I stay with Citizens?
It comes down to one comparison. Florida law makes your home ineligible for Citizens if a private insurer offers comparable coverage at a premium no more than 20% above your Citizens renewal premium.
Example: your estimated Citizens renewal premium is $3,250. The line is $3,250 x 1.20 = $3,900. Two insurers made offers.
| Offer | Estimated premium | Above Citizens by | Within 20%? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurer A | $3,700 | $450, about 13.8% | Yes |
| Insurer B | $4,050 | $800, about 24.6% | No |
Check the math: $450 divided by $3,250 is 0.138. $800 divided by $3,250 is 0.246.
Because Insurer A is within 20%, you can't stay with Citizens. You can still pick either private offer. If Insurer B were the only offer, you could stay, but you'd have to say so on the form.
When the law compares premiums, it counts any surcharge or assessment that's actually applied to each policy.
What happens if I ignore the letter?
Citizens assigns your policy to the private insurer that offered the lowest estimated premium. In the example above, that's Insurer A.
You'll then get a Notice of Assumption and Nonrenewal and a Certificate of Assumption. Assumption means the new insurer takes over your existing policy. Your Citizens premium and coverage stay the same until the current term ends. After that, the new insurer sends its own renewal offer.
After that, two rules apply.
- Citizens says there's no longer a 30-day period after assumption to return to Citizens.
- At the new insurer's first renewal, the 20% test runs again. If its renewal premium is within 20% of what Citizens would charge, you can't return to Citizens, even if you turn the private renewal down.
How do I compare the offer with my Citizens policy?
Price is the easy column. These lines take more care.
Hurricane deductible in dollars. Multiply your dwelling coverage by the percentage. A 2% deductible on $300,000 is $6,000. A 5% deductible on the same home is $15,000.
Moving mid-season. The hurricane deductible applies once per calendar year only within the same insurer or insurer group. If you used part of it on a Citizens claim this year and move to a new insurer, a later hurricane that same year starts a fresh, full deductible. The Florida hurricane deductible page runs through the state's own example of how that plays out.
Roof and water terms. Check whether roof damage is paid at full replacement cost or on a schedule that shrinks with roof age, and whether water damage has a lower cap.
Who backs the insurer. Since July 1, 2024, approved surplus lines insurers can make takeout offers on some second homes and other non-primary residences. Surplus lines companies aren't covered by the Florida Insurance Guaranty Association, the fund that pays claims when a licensed Florida insurer goes broke. Ask your agent which kind of insurer each offer comes from.
Assessment risk. Citizens has told its policyholders they could face assessments of up to 25% of premium after a severe storm season, which is more than private-market customers face.
The renewal is an estimate. The premium in the packet is an estimated renewal premium. The final number arrives with the private insurer's renewal.
To line the worksheets up against your current coverage, borrow the table in how to compare a home insurance renewal.
How do I respond?
Either way works, as long as it's done by the date on the Offer Form.
- Online. Go to the Policyholder Choice Selection page on citizensfla.com, enter your policy number and the registration code from the Offer Form, and make your choice. Add an email address if you want a confirmation. Without one, you won't get a confirmation email.
- Through your agent. Your agent can submit your choice for you. Citizens notes that if your agent registers for you, no confirmation email is sent, so ask the agent for proof.
If you stay with Citizens, more offers can arrive later. Each one needs its own response.
What to do next
- Find the response deadline on your Offer Form and put it on your calendar today.
- Multiply your estimated Citizens renewal premium by 1.20 and mark which offers fall under that line.
- Turn every hurricane deductible in the packet into dollars and check each insurer's roof and water terms.
- Ask your agent whether any offer is from a surplus lines insurer.
- Register your choice online or through your agent, and keep the confirmation.
If you'd like to understand Citizens itself before choosing, Citizens Property Insurance explained covers who qualifies, rate caps and the flood rule.
Common questions
Do I have to accept a Citizens takeout offer?
Only if an offer is within 20% of your estimated Citizens renewal premium. If every offer is more than 20% higher, you can stay with Citizens, but you or your agent must respond by the deadline on the offer form.
What happens to my premium after a takeout?
Citizens says your premium and coverage stay the same until your current term ends. Then the new insurer sends a renewal offer with its own price.
Can I go back to Citizens if I don't like the new insurer's renewal?
Only if the new insurer's renewal premium is more than 20% above what Citizens would charge. If it's within 20%, Citizens says you can't return, even if you turn the private renewal down.
Will I get another takeout offer if I stay?
You can. Citizens says policyholders who stay may get more offers later and need to respond to each one.
Sources
- Depopulation: Personal Lines, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- Making the Most of Depopulation with Policyholder Choice, Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- Florida Statutes 627.351, Insurance risk apportionment plans (2026), The Florida Senate
- Hurricane Debby, Depopulation Choices (policyholder newsletter), Citizens Property Insurance Corporation
- Bill Analysis and Fiscal Impact Statement, SB 1028 (2026), The Florida Senate
- Homeowners' Insurance: A Toolkit for Consumers, Florida Department of Financial Services